Tyler, Then and Now
Menu

1977: Plyler v. Doe

A tuition charge in Tyler’s schools, a class action filed in Tyler, and a Supreme Court decision in 1982.

Schools and colleges· 1977–1982

Tyler City SquareOakwood CemeteryGoodman-LeGrand HouseNear the ordnance plantCamp FordSmith County Jail (1881)St. James C.M.E. ChurchMarvin Methodist ChurchTexas CollegeCarnegie LibraryCotton Belt DepotBergfeld ParkThe 1910 courthouse (site)Black Wall Street (210 E. Erwin)Tyler Junior CollegeLiberty HallPeople’s National Bank BuildingU.S. Post Office and CourthouseBlackstone BuildingTyler Rose GardenLincoln ParkRose StadiumTyler Civic TheatreSmith County CourthouseUT TylerTyler Museum of ArtBroadway Square Mall
What the sources put on the map by 1982, over today’s streets.Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

The record

  1. 1893

    Hispanic families appear in Tyler city directories as early as 1893, when Domingo Garcia, listed as Mexican, runs a restaurant at Broadway and Erwin.1

  2. 1920s

    More Spanish surnames appear in the directories, most of them living just south of the Cotton Belt tracks and east of the Levee.1

  3. September 6, 1977

    At the start of the 1977-78 school year Tyler ISD begins charging $1,000 for each undocumented child. MALDEF lawyers file a class action against it, and superintendent James Plyler’s name goes on the case.2

  4. 1977

    The Handbook of Texas says MALDEF chose Tyler for a progressive judge (William Wayne Justice), sympathetic clients in families whose children held different immigration status, and a rural area where the media glare would be less.3

  5. September 14, 1978

    Judge Justice strikes down the state law as applied to Tyler ISD.3

  6. June 15, 1982

    The U.S. Supreme Court affirms the children’s right to attend, 5-4, in Plyler v. Doe.3

  7. 2000 and 2010

    The census counts 13,234 Hispanic or Latino residents in Tyler in 2000, about 16 percent, and 20,511 in 2010, about 21 percent.4

  8. 2014-15

    Tyler ISD has more than 18,000 students, about 45 percent Hispanic, nearly 30 percent Black and nearly 22 percent white.5

Notes

  1. National Register Multiple Property Documentation Form, Historic and Architectural Resources of Tyler, Texas (2001) (atlas.thc.texas.gov). Research notes

  2. Handbook of Texas: Plyler v. Doe (tshaonline.org). Research notes

  3. Handbook of Texas: Plyler v. Doe (tshaonline.org). Research notes

  4. U.S. Census Bureau, 2000 Census SF1 table P004 (Hispanic or Latino), Tyler city (data.census.gov); U.S. Census Bureau, 2010 Census SF1 table P4 (Hispanic or Latino origin), Tyler city (data.census.gov). Research notes

  5. Associated Press via Fox News, East Texas judge ends 1970 desegregation lawsuit in predominantly Hispanic school district (Aug. 27, 2016) (foxnews.com). Research notes

About this plate

  • A court case has no place on the map; this plate shows the city as it stood in 1982.
  • The faint linework is today’s map, from OpenStreetMap. How the map is made.